VAIRA ECONOMIC COMPASS · Business investment prototype
← Back to Compass decision tools

Should your business buy, lease or expand capacity?

Compare alternative ways to obtain productive capacity using discounted cash flows. This model separates the investment decision from the financing decision and uses illustrative assumptions, not market quotes.

1. Set common assumptions

Common benefits assume each option delivers equivalent capacity and output. If options provide different capacity, quality, timing or reliability, adjust the analysis outside this simplified comparison.

2. Compare three alternatives

A · Buy equipment

B · Lease equipment

C · Expand or upgrade plant

3. Economic interpretation

NPV is based on pre-tax incremental cash flows. Financing interest, depreciation, taxes, working capital, construction delays, downtime, capacity constraints, lease end-of-term obligations and exit penalties are excluded. The expansion option's additional benefit is relative to the common benefit assumed for the other options.

Decision checks: demand and capacity utilisation; implementation risk; technological obsolescence; residual-value uncertainty; flexibility; financing and liquidity constraints; workforce training and complementary investment. A positive NPV is not enough if a business cannot safely finance the initial expenditure.

Illustrative educational economic model, not personalised investment, tax, accounting or credit advice. Lease-versus-buy accounting and tax treatment may differ materially.

Compare how to finance your preferred option →